I too looked at the GTI and R32 before buying my FG. I think the Golf would be a good little performer around the city with great economy and reasonable resale. But for me the deciding factors were the FG XR6T has bulk power compaired to the Golf and plenty more room to fit people in and interior options. Disadvantages for the XR is more fuel costs, bad resale and maybe a little less build quality, not that I've had any issues with mine so far. Oh and one more advantage for the FG is 300rwkw with injectors and a tune. Gotta be happy with that. Benny